Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123
Results 21 to 28 of 28

Thread: Best cheap knife?

  1. #21
    Tribal Elder shepherd's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Location
    North Yorkshire/ West Yorkshire
    Posts
    1,275
    hi warren, that same knife has been mentioned earlier in the thread, except you have found it for cheaper! so many thanks! looks handy tool.. are your scouts using it? if so any feedback on how it performed? easy for youngsters to use? cheers

    *edit* - could be a good separate thread reviewing it, just a thought

    Shepherd
    Last edited by shepherd; 04-03-2016 at 08:40 AM.

  2. #22
    Woodsman Pootle's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Kernow
    Posts
    512
    I had a play with one of the hultafors knives today. and I'm now texting with one thumb as a result!
    I quite liked the knife but not as much as my old mora clipper. The handle is much nicer on the mora and it feels much more robust. but is be more than happy with the hults at that price.

  3. #23
    I just ordered 15 Hultafors Safety Knives from my tool shed. Ugly knives. Good prices, and they seem like good people to deal with. I have a couple of Hultafors Heavy Duty knives. One lives in a tool box and is regularly abused. The other I cut down to make the handle an inch or so shorter. I used that for quite a bit of bushcraft and it performed perfectly. It does everything my ESEE 3 does for a fraction of the cost. I bought one for my brother too, and he never felt the need for anything more fancy. I wouldn't normally encourage someone to buy a knife they hadn't used, but for under £5 you can't go wrong because if you hate it, it can live in the toolbox
    I do think Moras feel better in the hand though. The Hultafors handle is easier to cut down/sand down though.

  4. #24
    I rate the new style handled mora - nice comfortable feel and no chance of fingers straying from the handle onto the blade.

  5. #25
    Natural Born Bushcrafter Midge_Fodder's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    Sunny Dumfriesshire
    Posts
    899
    Mora are usually more than enough to cope with most bushcraft abuse. If I'm honest I only upgraded my knives because I like pretty things.

  6. #26
    Ranger OakAshandThorn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Location
    Connecticut ~ New England
    Posts
    2,465
    Ye gods, how did I miss this thread? :O

    My first fixed-blade outdoor knife was a *GASP* Bear Grylls Gerber. Still can't believe I paid *GASP* $60 for that piece of junk. I got tired of it pretty quick and upgraded to a Mora Companion heavy duty. What a world of difference - much better steel, more comfortable handle, not a "made in China" horror, and only $18 when I bought it 4 years ago. That was an excellent re-starter for me, and I still have it. About a year or two later, the Companion heavy duty started getting a lot of attention in the bushcraft community, with reviews popping up all over the place on the net; I have added my own review to the pot.

    The Companion heavy duty is something I consider to be a great basis for someone fairly new to outdoor living/bushcrafting because it's an excellent all-around performer. It can be used for moderate batoning, skinning and butchering game, fire preparation, food preparation, wood carving, and even making cordage (such as using the spine to remove flaky outer bark from plants so that inner bark fibres can be made into cordage). Plus, the rather large handle is great for people with beefy hands who often struggle to find a knife that fits comfortably in their hand. It's also excellent in winter when you're wearing gloves or mittens, because the larger handle is much easier to control than a knife with a smaller handle. And if the knife breaks? Big deal, it's only $18 .

    Other Mora knives such as the Classic series are also fantastic, though those are a little more task-specific.

    As far as a cheap pocket knife goes, something an ultralight backpacker or scout might carry, there's always the old stand-by of Victorinox and Wenger Swiss army knives. I have one myself, a Victorinox Huntsman. Alternatively, you could pick up a simple Opinel, which have become quite popular here in the States over the past few years. Svord peasant knives are also decent, though they may require a little fine tuning to even out the grind.

    But don't be fooled into thinking that you "need" a fixed-blade knife for all things outdoor/bushcraft related. You can do A LOT with the humble pocket knife, and for most people, a folding knife is all they really need. As far as what you want, well,....that takes a different route. Some people struggle to find "the one" until they pay top dollar for a custom knife, whilst others are content with their production blades.

    My favourite knife right now is a Martiini Arctic Circle puukko. It is budget-friendly at less than $50 (mine was $35 when I bought it two or three years ago), and a very nice start for someone who wants an authentic puukko. It might not have a thick tang for batoning, but I no longer use knives for batoning, and I've found that the puukko style suits my needs the best. I adore mine. It has been with me on many trips, always a reliable friend I can depend on. The blade is only 9 cm/3.5 inches, but that's the perfect size for what I need in a knife. And the thinner 2.5 mm blade with a high Scandinavian grind gives almost unrivaled slicing efficiency.

    So yeah...it really depends on what you want in a knife. Ask yourself what you want to use the knife for, and use that answer as a guide.
    Last edited by OakAshandThorn; 18-04-2016 at 12:52 AM.
    My blog, New England Bushcraft

    "Give me six hours to chop down a tree, and I will spend the first four sharpening the axe."
    ~ Abraham Lincoln

    "Be prepared, not scared."
    ~ Cody Lundin

  7. #27
    Natural Born Bushcrafter Midge_Fodder's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    Sunny Dumfriesshire
    Posts
    899
    Quote Originally Posted by OakAshandThorn View Post
    Ye gods, how did I miss this thread? :O

    My first fixed-blade outdoor knife was a *GASP* Bear Grylls Gerber. Still can't believe I paid *GASP* $60 for that piece of junk. I got tired of it pretty quick and upgraded to a Mora Companion heavy duty. What a world of difference - much better steel, more comfortable handle, not a "made in China" horror, and only $18 when I bought it 4 years ago. That was an excellent re-starter for me, and I still have it. About a year or two later, the Companion heavy duty started getting a lot of attention in the bushcraft community, with reviews popping up all over the place on the net; I have added my own review to the pot.

    The Companion heavy duty is something I consider to be a great basis for someone fairly new to outdoor living/bushcrafting because it's an excellent all-around performer. It can be used for moderate batoning, skinning and butchering game, fire preparation, food preparation, wood carving, and even making cordage (such as using the spine to remove flaky outer bark from plants so that inner bark fibres can be made into cordage). Plus, the rather large handle is great for people with beefy hands who often struggle to find a knife that fits comfortably in their hand. It's also excellent in winter when you're wearing gloves or mittens, because the larger handle is much easier to control than a knife with a smaller handle. And if the knife breaks? Big deal, it's only $18 .

    Other Mora knives such as the Classic series are also fantastic, though those are a little more task-specific.

    As far as a cheap pocket knife goes, something an ultralight backpacker or scout might carry, there's always the old stand-by of Victorinox and Wenger Swiss army knives. I have one myself, a Victorinox Huntsman. Alternatively, you could pick up a simple Opinel, which have become quite popular here in the States over the past few years. Svord peasant knives are also decent, though they may require a little fine tuning to even out the grind.

    But don't be fooled into thinking that you "need" a fixed-blade knife for all things outdoor/bushcraft related. You can do A LOT with the humble pocket knife, and for most people, a folding knife is all they really need. As far as what you want, well,....that takes a different route. Some people struggle to find "the one" until they pay top dollar for a custom knife, whilst others are content with their production blades.

    My favourite knife right now is a Martiini Arctic Circle puukko. It is budget-friendly at less than $50 (mine was $35 when I bought it two or three years ago), and a very nice start for someone who wants an authentic puukko. It might not have a thick tang for batoning, but I no longer use knives for batoning, and I've found that the puukko style suits my needs the best. I adore mine. It has been with me on many trips, always a reliable friend I can depend on. The blade is only 9 cm/3.5 inches, but that's the perfect size for what I need in a knife. And the thinner 2.5 mm blade with a high Scandinavian grind gives almost unrivaled slicing efficiency.

    So yeah...it really depends on what you want in a knife. Ask yourself what you want to use the knife for, and use that answer as a guide.
    Kind of goes hand in hand with the question, do you buy an axe. Tbh Like yourself I never Barton as I always have an axe or hatchet, so battoning a knife never happens.
    Border Bushcrafters

    Isn't it nice when someone says "that's a great piece of kit, where did you buy that", then you can modestly reply "you can't buy it, I made it myself". The moral is, it's amazing what you can achieve if you put your mind to it.

    "No better burden can a man carry on the road, than a store of common sense." - Hávamál: 10

    http://midgefodderbushcraft.blogspot.co.uk

  8. #28
    thread ressurect, interesting on the hultafors now I've looked more closely at them. they cant be any worse than the moras with the stubby tang I used to hand out to the scouts broken loads of them but they are cheap enough to scrap.

    one of the cheapest and best knives I have is a re purposed chefs knife I cut down and reground to prove a point to someone that expensive does not mean better. its stainless but you can remodel old carbon ones if you can find them at car boots and the like. good handle and a full tang, sheath made from cereal packet, velcro and duct tape.

    and my old wood handled moras with the button loop and no guard - still razor sharp 30 years on. 4 quid if my addled memory is correct

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •